Goodfellows
4.5(4k+)•
DashPass•
Italian•
Store Info
DashPass
4.5(4k+)•
$$•Italian
Since 1989, we have been a family-owned and run business. Since 2012, we've lived in Anderson Township.
Full Menu
4:00 pm - 10:40 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
16" Cheese
$20.80
•95% (20)
12" Cheese
$16.90
•94% (17)
9" Cheese
$11.05
•85% (14)
16" Brent the Bull
$31.20
•100% (6)
Tre Skins
$11.70
•80% (10)
Side House Salad
$6.50
•80% (25)
100+ recent orders
Reviews4k+ ratings • 40+ public reviews
4.5
of 5 stars
J
Jerri L
1 contributions07/05/25
• DoorDash orderI absolutely love the Sheila pretzel bites , unfortunately, they were out tonight. But the wonderful staff that they had give me a free italian cheese bread and that might be my second favorite, or maybe my first, depending on my mood for the day, everything that i've had here has been absolutely delicious.And I couldn't say better things about the staff they're all amazing
K
Kelvin A
11 contributions08/04/25
• DoorDash orderI ordered the Phenix's Pesto Calzone without the Pesto & added the items I wanted in the Calzone, basically a build your own Calzone and it was the best Calzone I ever had. Absolutely Delicious!!! The Lindsey's Black Bean Burger and the Scott's Spaghetti is good. Order extra Garlic Toast because it's so good ur going to want more.
B
Becky S
Emerging Expert • 20 contributions09/08/25
• DoorDash orderAn excellent pizza! crispy crust, just the right amount of sauce and fresh ingredients! Will be coming back for more!
J
Jessica F
3 contributions3 days ago
• DoorDash orderMy pizza was cold, and burnt. I paid for extra cheese and there was barely any cheese on it. So much pizza sauce. Usually this place Is the best pizza but it was from from this time!
J
Josh D
8 contributions11/03/22
• DoorDash orderI order the make your own pizza and add feta cheese with some other stuff and it's out of this world!! The sandwiches and calzones are awesome too. The only thing I didn't like was the pepperoni chips, something I thought would be great, but really kinda yuck.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store