I like to pour the Broccoli and Cheddar over the Justaspud® . It's delicious. The Butter Pecan Cheesecake is so good! Very rich and a good sized portion for the price. I tried the new Witch's Brew Caramel Apple Lemonade for Fall, and I loved it! Tart green apple and lemon at first, and then a light taste of Caramel at the end.
S
Stacy H
7 contributions
04/08/25
• DoorDash order
Love Mcalisters! The food is always nice and fresh. The soup is always perfect! The best comfort food to me!!!! Definitely would order again! The sandwich looks just like the picture. Perfect size portions on everything!
J
Joseph C
Emerging Expert • 4 contributions
05/03/25
• DoorDash order
It came fast and the soup was packaged really well, still hot! But the the Grilled Chicken Salad was tiny. When I pay $14 for a salad, I would expect it to be massive. This didnt even fill the container and felt more like an appetizer.
B
Breeanne W
5 contributions
26/12/24
• DoorDash order
The Justaspud® is always great - seriously a huge potato and it's pretty fluffy with the skin rarely overdone. The Broccoli and Cheddar soup is suuuuuuuper good. It's creamy and rich and very flavorful with just enough substance/chunks. I like to pour the soup over the plain potato. They've also (so far and I order pretty regularly) never forgotten an item or got our order wrong. It's usually packaged really well too so the soup doesn't spill.
S
Shane H
Local Expert • 79 contributions
11/08/25
• DoorDash order
The New Yorker is notable both for its taste and the massive amount of corn beef you get in the sandwich
one of my go-to sandwiches.
8 have tried most of their menu. I've yet to find a sandwich that's not awesome
The New Yorker is no exception
