Holy smokes this pizza is wayyyyyy over loaded with cheese and the crust is just tough flavorless. Not tough as in burnt its tough as in card board chewy sort of like a pizza luncheable. The chicken wings were so insanely over cooked and too crunchy near the ends to dare try and eat for fear of breaking a tooth. Only reason theres two stars is because the portions of the meh food were at least large and mostly edible.
T
Tori M
2 contributions
10/4/23
• DoorDash order
I feel like how excited I was for this was what made it bad. You name your place turtle time I gotta eat it. Well I had the Avocado Steak Fries they were crazy disappointing soggy I was like okay darn it oh well. on to the Bavarian Cream Filled Churros man I was hoping for filling was disappointed, nice crisp outside pretty good churro by itself I was just excited for the filling. The only reason this store begrudgingly gets 4 stars is the Chocolate Molten Lava Cake the only complaint I had was size for price. Itty bitty bunt with chocolate in the middle and a small single scoop of ice cream over 10 bucks cool. All around temper your expectations it's not like it's bad but it's not good either. Don't think they're getting a second chance from me.
G
Glenn T
9 contributions
1/20/24
• DoorDash order
Had high hopes of locating a great small pizzeria and chose Turtle. I've owned a brick oven pizzeria before so idohave some experience.
First, Door Dash got lost - I was watching driver go passed my location several times and not Turtles fault.
When it did arrive, the pie looked undercooked and was rather light on the toppings. So light, I had to double check my order.
I tasted a slice proved it to be undercooked. I put a couple of slices in the toaster oven and it helped.
The crust was similar to frozen pizza, not much taste. And neither crispy nor chewy- just sirtathere. Sauce was probably the best part.
I was really hoping to find my go to; they arent it for me.
