North of Brooklyn Pizzeria’s Truffle Shuffle (Medium) is a highlight in Toronto’s bustling pizza scene, offering a New York-style pie with a thin, crispy crust topped with truffle cream, mozzarella, smoked cheddar, cremini mushrooms, caramelized onions, chives, and a hint of lemon zest. This indulgent combination delivers a rich, earthy flavor with a modern take.
By comparison, other competitors like Pizzeria Libretto’s Neapolitan-style truffle specials, like the “Truff-Ghi,” features a soft, wood-fired crust with a lighter truffle sauce and mushrooms, emphasizing rustic Italian simplicity. Maker Pizza’s sesame-crusted pies or Queen Margherita’s classic Neapolitan focus are noteworthy but they rarely match the truffle-driven decadence of this pizza. For Toronto residents craving a bold, New York-style pizza bursting with flavor, North of Brooklyn’s Truffle Shuffle is the top pick to order.
The truffle isn't overpowering and I always enjoy paring it with the Creamy Garlic Dip!
S
Sara S
13 contributions
7/30/25
• DoorDash order
Wow, just wow! The hype is real folks, that's all I can say! If you're a fan of vodka sauce then you'll love the Vodka Verde (Medium).
The Chocolate Budino was also scrumptious and only a little sweet--- mostly just velvety smooth and cocoa-y!
I'm a new fan, will absolutely be reordering! <3
T
Thomas B
6 contributions
1/9/25
• DoorDash order
This is good pizza!! Thin, crispy, airy crust, generous quality toppings - full of flavour. Garlic dip is fresh and delicious.
C
Christina R
4 contributions
8/22/22
• DoorDash order
Might be the best pizza we have had in years. Killer Bee (Large) was packed with flavor. The thin crust is charred to  perfection.
S
Shirley H
1 contributions
4/23/24
• DoorDash order
Ordered: Killer Bee (Medium), Truffle Shuffle (Medium), Garlic Knots
First time ordering from this location. I consider the Queen St location to be one of the best pizza in Toronto. Church St. location was subpar. Toppings were thrown on haphazardly, not evenly distributed. The shape of the Truffle Shuffle (Medium) was oblong thus fitted awkwardly in box. Slices were not cut with care. Garlic Knots were so over done, they could not be bitten through. Utter disappointment!
