It's nice when they get the order right. I think the cost on the cookie was too much, should've been bigger at that price. But it was really good. Made perfect. I'd buy the chicken, if it weren't so expensive.
S
Shelly T
1 contributions
3 days ago
• DoorDash order
EVERYTHING was absolutely amazing, wonderful, perfectly cooked, seasoned well, just WOW. The Classic Italian, Steak Hoagie, and Nightsticks were hot, fresh, and tasty. probably the best made food we've ever had! absolutely eat here again, a LOT!
K
Kelsey W
1 contributions
7/5/25
• DoorDash order
Honestly, this might have been the best pizza I've had. Even more surprising was how delicious fries and a Family Size Chocolate Chip Cookie (basically a cookie pie) from a pizza place could be! Literally the best take out we have had in months. 2 large pizzas was enough for 5 of us and so was the cookie. All of it was still super hot, fresh and perfect despite coming across state lanes to deliver
K
Kiva D
2 contributions
9/20/24
• DoorDash order
I was recommended NYPD by my buddy Eric, and it was amazing 10/10, screw dominoes and papa johns, I love this more. I ordered the 14" Large Chicken Alfredo and I was upset at first because it was a pizza and I was confused but it was the best thing I've ever had I love it, this is my new pizza place.
P
Paul D
Emerging Expert • 65 contributions
7/31/25
• DoorDash order
Anytime I've ordered from here, it's never a disappointment. The prices for the pizza is really good and the portions is good too. I ordered the Meatball Hoagie and it's awesome. The NYPD Cinnamon Bites are really good and I order it every time I place an order. Everything just taste fresh and made from scratch and not processed like other pizza places. I will definitely continue to order from here.
