We think that love can be baked, sliced, grilled, melted, shredded, and finally wrapped into a neat little package. At Toasty Sandwich Shop, we put your cravings first, and we make sure to bring your …
1000/10 & if your picky like me with breakfast sandwhiches , then this is your spot ! Best BACON EGG & CHEESE ROLL i've ever had. Would highly recommend . HAZELNUT LATTE didnt stand a chance . Was devoured in 2 minutes (im also 9 months pregnant) . BUFFALO CHICKEN CHEESE FRIES SMALL were the star of the show though . I had to take a picture because I couldnt believe my eyes . A small order is so filling . Worth whatever you will spend. Will be ordering again tomorrow and everyday from now on !
R
Rome C
1 contributions
7/31/25
• DoorDash order
MAGIC CHOPPED CHEESE is delicious. I get this so often and it's always fresh, warm and tasty. The ICED CARAMEL LATTE is a must also. You won't regret ordering from this place. All of their sandwiches are delicious!!
J
Jenni R
Emerging Expert • 10 contributions
7/7/25
• DoorDash order
Added avocado & tomato to The Midnight sandwich... would've preferred without the yellow cheese (mozzarella was enough), but Door Dash lets you add things but not subtract. Overall, sandwich & cheese fries were really good and excellent price for the area. Arrived warm. Would definitely recommend!
F
Franijo P
1 contributions
11/5/24
• DoorDash order
Their new bowls are outstanding, had the Buffalo one and the fried chicken one, no changes. Good ingredients and very tasty. The portion size is huge, so make sure you get extra dressing.
N
Nathan F
4 contributions
7/21/22
• DoorDash order
Hands-down best sandwich shop around. I've been waiting so long for a Shop Like This in YONKERS. I asked for a custom sandwich and they absolutely smashed it out of the park. I never review places. This place rocks!! Oh did I mention espresso and coffee?! YUM
